European Works Councils under Irish Law
10 July 2020
European Works Councils are the only legally-mandated bodies for transnational information and consultation with employees in the world.
This inbrief details which employers can be required to establish an EWC and the rules that apply to them. It also considers steps that they can take if they wish to move their EWC to Ireland in preparation for the end of the UK’s Brexit transition period.
The content includes:
Background on EWCs
A European Works Council (a “EWC”) is a body that facilitates information and consultation with European employees on transnational issues. EWCs are composed of employees’ representatives from each country that is a member of either or both of the European Union and the European Economic Area, and the UK during its Brexit transition period, in which a business has employees (a “Member State”). EWCs operate separately from national information and consultation bodies. They derive from Directive 2009/38/EC (the “EWC Directive”) as transposed into Irish law by the Transnational Information and Consultation of Employees Act 1996 (as amended) (“TICEA”). An EWC operating under an agreement is technically a “European Employees’ Forum” and an EWC operating under the default subsidiary requirements is a “European Works Council”. For ease, this inbrief refers to both kinds of bodies as an EWC.
When do the EWC Directive and TICEA apply?
The EWC Directive applies to undertakings or groups of undertakings with at least 1,000 employees in Member States and at least 150 employees in each of two Member States. Even if the EWC Directive applies then TICEA will only apply if an employer’s central management is situated in Ireland. Central management is the management that can exert ultimate control over an undertaking or group, or which acts as the representative agent of such management located outside of a Member State (such as in the United States).
Which rules apply?
The EWC Directive recast Directive 94/45/EC as extended to the UK by Directive 97/74/EC when the UK ended its opt-out from the Social Chapter. This means that there are three legal frameworks:
- EWCs established prior to 22 September 1996 in advance of a business falling within the scope of Directive 94/45/EC (commonly known as “Article 13” agreements) or prior to 15 December 1999 in advance of falling within its scope as extended by Directive 97/74/EC (commonly known as “Article 3” agreements). These EWCs generally fall outside of the scope of the EWC Directive and TICEA although if a business’s structure changes significantly or the agreement terminates then management may need to negotiate a new agreement fully subject to both the EWC Directive and TICEA;
- EWCs established or revised between 5 June 2009 and 5 June 2011. These EWCs generally fall outside of the scope of the EWC Directive and TICEA although if a business’s structure changes significantly or the agreement terminates then management may need to negotiate a new agreement fully subject to both the EWC Directive and TICEA. However, unlike “Article 13” and “Article 3” agreements, these agreements are subject to Directive 94/45/EC and TICEA as in force prior to 5 June 2011; and
- EWCs which are fully subject to both the EWC Directive and TICEA.
This guide focuses on EWCs that are fully subject to both the EWC Directive and TICEA. It is nevertheless of relevance to all businesses as the rules on adaptation apply to all EWCS if a business’s structure changes significantly.
Nomination of a representative agent and Brexit
Central managements located in a country outside of the European Union and the European Economic Area that have not already nominated a representative agent should carefully consider proactively nominating one in Ireland. A default representative agent will otherwise be deemed to exist in the Member State in which the group undertaking which employs the greatest number of employees is situated. Legislation significantly less favourable to employers than TICEA might then apply.
Central managements located in the UK may not yet nominate an Irish representative agent because EU law remains applicable to and in the UK during its Brexit transition period. However, we regularly advise on conditional nominations that will take immediate effect at the end of the UK’s Brexit transition period.
All central managements with an existing UK representative agent may conditionally nominate a replacement one with effect from the end of the Brexit transition period. Some but not all may also be able to make such a nomination with immediate effect depending on whether the current representative agent is contractually bound by an existing EWC agreement. Issues arise in the course of a central management’s obligations transitioning from being governed by UK law to Irish law. These include issues such as the provision of training. We regularly advise on them as part of advising on all kinds of nominations.
Employees and their representatives may request information for the purpose of determining whether TICEA applies to an employer. The employer must then provide specified information on its employee numbers and on the structure of its workforce.
Commencing the process to establish an EWC
An employer may choose voluntarily to establish an EWC but is under no obligation to establish one unless it receives a written request made by or on behalf of at least 100 employees from at least two Member States.
Establishing a special negotiating body
An employer must establish a special negotiating body (an “SNB”) to negotiate an EWC agreement once it has chosen to establish an EWC or received a valid request. An SNB is a body of employees’ representatives that has the sole purpose of negotiating an EWC agreement. It does not have any information and consultation role.
An SNB must be composed to consist of one employees’ representative from each Member State in which an employer has employees and an additional employees’ representative from each Member State in respect of each tranche or fraction of 10% of employees who are employed in that Member State. Members of the SNB must be appointed or elected in accordance of the laws of the Member State in which they are employed. The employer must bear all costs involved in establishing the SNB.
Negotiations with an SNB
Employers must initiate negotiations with its SNB within six months of the commencement of the process for establishing an EWC. The employer and the members of the SNB must then work in a spirit of cooperation with a view to reaching a written agreement on the detailed arrangements for the information and consultation of employees. Negotiations may and often do last for up to three years and an SNB’s decisions must be made by a majority of its members.
Members of an SNB enjoy rights to assist them to negotiate an EWC agreement including:
- to meet without management before and after any meetings with management;
- to be assisted by experts of their choice and for management to pay for the reasonable costs of one such expert per meeting;
- to receive training to the extent necessary for the exercise of their duties;
- for management to pay for their reasonable and necessary costs relating to the negotiations such as travel expenses, accommodation expenses, and translation and interpretation support; and
- paid time off work for the performance of their duties.
The SNB and management enjoy significant flexibility to negotiate the precise terms of an EWC agreement but it must detail the following:
- the group companies covered by the EWC agreement;
- the composition of the EWC, the number of its members, the allocation of seats and the term of office of its members;
- the functions and the procedure for information and consultation of the EWC;
- arrangements to link information and consultation of the EWC with information and consultation of national employee representation bodies;
- the venue, frequency and duration of meetings of the EWC;
- the composition, procedure for appointment, function and procedural rules of any select committee of the EWC;
- the financial and material resources to be allocated to the EWC; and
- the date of entry into force of the EWC agreement, its duration, the arrangements for amending or terminating it, and the circumstances and manner in which it is to be renegotiated including if the structure of the business changes significantly.
If it is not possible to conclude an EWC agreement within three years then an EWC must be established operating under the subsidiary requirements detailed in TICEA. These provide a default set of provisions under which the EWC must operate. They provide for one annual meeting between the EWC and central management to facilitate information and consultation on the overall state of the business. They also provide for additional meetings in the event of exceptional circumstances affecting employees’ interests to a considerable extent, such as in the event of significant collective redundancies in more than one Member State.
The SNB and management may also choose for the subsidiary requirements to apply at any time and they apply by default if management fails to initiate negotiations within six months of receiving a valid request.
Operation of an EWC
The EWC agreement or the subsidiary requirements govern an EWC’s operation. TICEA nevertheless imposes certain overarching obligations with which management must comply. These include:
- not dismissing or subjecting employees’ representatives to any form of detriment in connection with their proper performance of their duties; and
- providing employees’ representatives with the means required for them to fulfil their duties, training to the extent necessary for the exercise of their duties; and paid time off to perform their duties and receive training.
Management may give information to an EWC on a confidential basis if it is commercially sensitive. It does not need to give information to employees’ representatives at all if that would be prejudicial to or otherwise seriously harm its interests.
If the structure of a group with a EWC changes significantly then, in certain circumstances, it can be required to negotiate a new EWC Agreement. This is one of the ways in which “Article 13” agreements, “Article 3” agreements and agreements dating from between 5 June 2009 and 5 June 2011 are slowly being replaced by agreements fully subject to both the EWC Directive and TICEA.
Disputes regarding the rights of individual employees’ representatives may be resolved by either the Workplace Relations Commission or by arbitration. Disputes regarding the confidentiality of information and regarding the interpretation or operation of EWC agreements are resolved by arbitration. Disputes regarding management’s compliance with the subsidiary requirements may be resolved by the Workplace Relations Commission and, upon further request, by the Labour Court.
EWCs cannot slow down managerial decision-making02 August 2019
In the UK’s first appeal case on the operation of a European Works Council (“EWC”), the Employment Appeal Tribunal (“EAT”) has ruled that EWCs cannot slow down managerial decision-making by delaying the provision of an opinion after being informed and consulted.
UK CAC upholds the relocation of European Works Council arrangements to Ireland due to Brexit21 June 2019
The Central Arbitration Committee (“CAC”) has ruled that multinational companies headquartered outside of the European Union are not prohibited from relocating their European Works Council (“EWC”) arrangements from the UK in anticipation of Brexit. Relocation does not undermine employees’ information and consultation rights and is in accordance with the fundamental EU law principle of freedom of establishment.
EU Commission confirms its views on EWCs and a “no-deal” Brexit01 May 2019
The European Commission (“EC”) has recently revised its March 2018 guidance on the legal repercussions of the UK’s withdrawal from the EU for European Work’s Councils (“EWCs”), including the implications of a “no-deal” Brexit.
EAT rules in first UK appeal case on European Works Councils20 March 2019
In the UK’s first ever appeal case on European Works Councils (“EWCs”), the Employment Appeal Tribunal (“EAT”) has ruled that a Special Negotiating Body (“SNB”) can continue to exist after the third anniversary of a request to establish a EWC.
Update on European Works Councils - will Brexit frustrate your EWC?28 February 2019
The final form of Brexit remains uncertain, as does its impact on European Works Councils (“EWCs”) that are governed by UK law.
Brexit and European Works Councils - a status update and what you need to do next29 January 2019
The final form of Brexit remains uncertain as does its impact on European Works Councils (“EWCs”), the area of employment law that it will most immediately and profoundly affect. This article guides you through the current state of play and suggests how best to prepare for what might happen to your existing UK law-governed EWC arrangements.