Corporate Building
ESG remains a “hot topic”; this year, the Environmental pillar has been a key area of focus. Governance, the third pillar in the ESG framework, has not received the same level of attention, but is important for companies in the UK to consider, as they may be subject to corporate governance reporting requirements if they meet certain criteria.

What is Corporate Governance?

Corporate governance relates to the way companies are managed and steered by their directors in order to maintain integrity, legal compliance and positive relationships with stakeholders (including both shareholders and employees). The Companies Act 2006 (“CA 2006”) is the main piece of legislation regulating company law in England and imposes general statutory duties on directors. For further information on CA 2006 duties of directors to ensure good corporate governance, please refer to our detailed overview.

Corporate Governance Reporting Requirements – what are they and who do they apply to?

In addition to ensuring compliance with their statutory directors’ duties, companies meeting the relevant conditions must also report on compliance with their statutory duties, as well as other aspects of corporate governance. The Companies (Miscellaneous Reporting) Regulations 2018 (“Regulations”) introduced these additional corporate governance reporting requirements and require companies to include new content in their annual reports, essentially summarising the measures that they have taken around corporate governance. The Regulations apply to reporting on financial years starting on or after 1 January 2019.

A summary of the reporting requirements, the thresholds for each reporting requirement and further guidance on how to comply is provided in the table below.

Reporting requirements

Thresholds

How to comply

Section 172 Statement

The requirement to prepare a Section 172 Statement applies to all companies, except those that qualify as medium-sized companies under sections 465 and 467,CA 2006. UK incorporated companies that meet at least two of the following will qualify as a medium-sized company:

  • Turnover of £36m or less.
  • Balance sheet total of £18m or less.
  • 250 employees or less.

Group Treatment: All qualifying companies, including subsidiaries, must meet these reporting requirements. This is the case even where the parent company is required to produce a consolidated “group strategic report” or “group directors’ report”.

If a subsidiary company meets the qualifying conditions and the parent does not, but the parent prepares consolidated group accounts, the parent company must publish a Section 172(1) Statement as part of the group strategic report, as the parent qualifies through the process of consolidation. Note, this does not remove the separate requirement for the subsidiary to report on how its own directors have had regard to publish a Section 172(1) Statement.

If both the parent company and the subsidiary are below the qualifying conditions but, through consolidation, the parent company meets the threshold for preparing a Section 172(1) Statement, the parent company must prepare a Section 172(1) Statement. The subsidiary does not need to because it is below the relevant threshold.

Companies in scope must include a Section 172 Statement in their strategic report setting out how directors have complied with their duty to promote the success of the company for the benefit of its members as a whole, having regard to the matters in s172 (1)(a)-(f) of the Companies Act 2006 (the “s172 Duty”):

  • The likely consequences of any decision in the long term.
  • The interests of the company's employees.
  • The need to foster the company's business relationships with suppliers, customers and others.
  • The impact of the company's operations on the community and the environment.
  • The desirability of the company maintaining a reputation for high standards of business conduct.
  • The need to act fairly as between members of the company.


The Section 172 Statement must be provided in a separately identifiable statement within the strategic report.

The statement must also be made available online by all companies in scope. As unquoted companies are not required to publish their annual report on a website, they must ensure that the Section 172(1) statement is available on a website. This does not need to be the company’s own website – it can be the website of a parent company provided it identifies the company in question.

According to guidance published in November 2018 by the Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy, Companies should include information on some or all the following in their Section 172(1) Statements:

  • The issues, factors and stakeholders the directors consider relevant in complying with the s172 Duty and how they have formed that opinion.
  • The main methods the directors have used to engage with stakeholders and understand the issues to which they must have regard.
  • Information on the effect of that regard on the company’s decisions and strategies during the financial year.

Statement of engagement with suppliers

Same as Thresholds - Section 172 Statement.
 
Companies in scope must include a Statement of engagement with suppliers, customers and others in their directors’ reports, summarising how directors have engaged with suppliers, customers and others in a business relationship with the company.

The purpose of this additional requirement is to ensure that directors report on how they have complied with this aspect of the s172 Duty in respect of matters that are not of sufficient strategic importance to be included in the strategic report that year.

Statement of engagement with employees

The requirement to prepare a Statement of engagement with employees applies to UK incorporated companies with more than 250 UK employees.

If the company is a parent company, it is the number of employees in the group and not just the company itself that is used.

Group Treatment: same as above.

Companies in scope must include a Statement of engagement with employees in their directors’ reports, summarising how directors have engaged with employees and taken account of their interests. This expands on the information about employee engagement matters that companies already have to include in their directors’ report.

Again, the purpose of this additional requirement is to ensure that directors report on how they have complied with this aspect of the s172 Duty in respect of matters that are not of sufficient strategic importance to be included in the strategic report that year.

Statement of corporate governance arrangements

The requirement to prepare a Statement of corporate governance arrangements applies to UK incorporated companies with either:

  • More than 2,000 global employees.

  • AS turnover over £200 million globally and a balance sheet total over £2 billion globally.

Premium and standard listed companies which are already required to report on their corporate governance arrangements under DTR (Disclosure Guidance and Transparency Rules) 7.2 are not within scope. Community interest companies and charitable companies are also exempted.

Group Treatment:

The employee threshold and the turnover and balance sheet thresholds should be calculated at an individual company level only. No consolidation across a group is required for these thresholds.

Every company meeting the qualifying thresholds on its own must comply with the new reporting requirement, including subsidiaries. This includes both subsidiaries of listed companies required to meet the UK Corporate Governance Code and subsidiaries of parent companies which prepare a consolidated group directors’ report. The UK subsidiary of a listed overseas parent which applies an overseas code must also prepare a corporate governance statement.

Companies in scope must include a Statement of corporate governance arrangements in the directors’ report, explaining the corporate governance arrangements applied by the company.

The statement must also be published online on a website maintained by or on behalf of the company.

Companies can choose the most appropriate code for them, or none, although if a company does not apply a code, it must explain why that is the case and what corporate governance arrangements have been made. If the company has departed from its chosen code, it must set out the respects in which it did so, and the reasons.

Companies are expected to provide sufficient information to ensure that their corporate governance arrangements are explained.

The Government hopes that the corporate governance principles for large private companies developed by James Wates and a coalition group (the “Wates Principles”) will be widely adopted. There is also the UK Corporate Governance Code, which companies with a premium listing on the London Stock Exchange must comply with. The Financial Reporting Council has announced that this year, the UK Corporate Governance Code will be updated for the first time since 2018.

Companies can also choose a foreign corporate governance code if appropriate.

Reporting requirements:

Thresholds - Section 172 Statement

The requirement to prepare a Section 172 Statement applies to all companies, except those that qualify as medium-sized companies under sections 465 and 467,CA 2006. UK incorporated companies that meet at least two of the following will qualify as a medium-sized company:

  • Turnover of £36m or less.
  • Balance sheet total of £18m or less.
  • 250 employees or less.

Group Treatment: All qualifying companies, including subsidiaries, must meet these reporting requirements. This is the case even where the parent company is required to produce a consolidated “group strategic report” or “group directors’ report”.

If a subsidiary company meets the qualifying conditions and the parent does not, but the parent prepares consolidated group accounts, the parent company must publish a Section 172(1) Statement as part of the group strategic report, as the parent qualifies through the process of consolidation. Note, this does not remove the separate requirement for the subsidiary to report on how its own directors have had regard to publish a Section 172(1) Statement.

If both the parent company and the subsidiary are below the qualifying conditions but, through consolidation, the parent company meets the threshold for preparing a Section 172(1) Statement, the parent company must prepare a Section 172(1) Statement. The subsidiary does not need to because it is below the relevant threshold.

How to comply - Section 172 Statement

Companies in scope must include a Section 172 Statement in their strategic report setting out how directors have complied with their duty to promote the success of the company for the benefit of its members as a whole, having regard to the matters in s172 (1)(a)-(f) of the Companies Act 2006 (the “s172 Duty”):

  • The likely consequences of any decision in the long term.
  • The interests of the company's employees.
  • The need to foster the company's business relationships with suppliers, customers and others.
  • The impact of the company's operations on the community and the environment.
  • The desirability of the company maintaining a reputation for high standards of business conduct.
  • The need to act fairly as between members of the company.


The Section 172 Statement must be provided in a separately identifiable statement within the strategic report.

The statement must also be made available online by all companies in scope. As unquoted companies are not required to publish their annual report on a website, they must ensure that the Section 172(1) statement is available on a website. This does not need to be the company’s own website – it can be the website of a parent company provided it identifies the company in question.

According to guidance published in November 2018 by the Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy, Companies should include information on some or all the following in their Section 172(1) Statements:

  • The issues, factors and stakeholders the directors consider relevant in complying with the s172 Duty and how they have formed that opinion.
  • The main methods the directors have used to engage with stakeholders and understand the issues to which they must have regard.
  • Information on the effect of that regard on the company’s decisions and strategies during the financial year.

Thresholds - Statement of engagement with suppliers

Same as above.

How to comply - Statement of engagement with suppliers

Companies in scope must include a Statement of engagement with suppliers, customers and others in their directors’ reports, summarising how directors have engaged with suppliers, customers and others in a business relationship with the company.

The purpose of this additional requirement is to ensure that directors report on how they have complied with this aspect of the s172 Duty in respect of matters that are not of sufficient strategic importance to be included in the strategic report that year.

Thresholds - Statement of engagement with employees

The requirement to prepare a Statement of engagement with employees applies to UK incorporated companies with more than 250 UK employees.

If the company is a parent company, it is the number of employees in the group and not just the company itself that is used.

Group Treatment: same as above.

How to comply - Statement of engagement with employees

Companies in scope must include a Statement of engagement with employees in their directors’ reports, summarising how directors have engaged with employees and taken account of their interests. This expands on the information about employee engagement matters that companies already have to include in their directors’ report.

Again, the purpose of this additional requirement is to ensure that directors report on how they have complied with this aspect of the s172 Duty in respect of matters that are not of sufficient strategic importance to be included in the strategic report that year.

Thresholds - Statement of corporate governance arrangements

The requirement to prepare a Statement of corporate governance arrangements applies to UK incorporated companies with either:

  • More than 2,000 global employees.

  • AS turnover over £200 million globally and a balance sheet total over £2 billion globally.

Premium and standard listed companies which are already required to report on their corporate governance arrangements under DTR (Disclosure Guidance and Transparency Rules) 7.2 are not within scope. Community interest companies and charitable companies are also exempted.

Group Treatment:

The employee threshold and the turnover and balance sheet thresholds should be calculated at an individual company level only. No consolidation across a group is required for these thresholds.

Every company meeting the qualifying thresholds on its own must comply with the new reporting requirement, including subsidiaries. This includes both subsidiaries of listed companies required to meet the UK Corporate Governance Code and subsidiaries of parent companies which prepare a consolidated group directors’ report. The UK subsidiary of a listed overseas parent which applies an overseas code must also prepare a corporate governance statement.

How to comply - Statement of corporate governance arrangements

Companies in scope must include a Statement of corporate governance arrangements in the directors’ report, explaining the corporate governance arrangements applied by the company.

The statement must also be published online on a website maintained by or on behalf of the company.

Companies can choose the most appropriate code for them, or none, although if a company does not apply a code, it must explain why that is the case and what corporate governance arrangements have been made. If the company has departed from its chosen code, it must set out the respects in which it did so, and the reasons.

Companies are expected to provide sufficient information to ensure that their corporate governance arrangements are explained.

The Government hopes that the corporate governance principles for large private companies developed by James Wates and a coalition group (the “Wates Principles”) will be widely adopted. There is also the UK Corporate Governance Code, which companies with a premium listing on the London Stock Exchange must comply with. The Financial Reporting Council has announced that this year, the UK Corporate Governance Code will be updated for the first time since 2018.

Companies can also choose a foreign corporate governance code if appropriate.

 

Penalties for non-compliance

The Regulations amend the CA 2006 and the Companies (Audit, Investigations and Community Enterprise) Act 2004 by expanding the matters that private companies already need to report on in their strategic report and directors’ report. Under the CA 2006 and the Companies (Audit, Investigations and Community Enterprise) Act 2004, if the directors of a company knowingly do not comply with any of the required provisions, or are reckless as to their compliance, they will be committing an offence.

The Regulations also introduce new offences around online publication. If the directors of a company fail to make the s172 statement or the corporate governance arrangements statement available online, they will be committing a separate offence and will be liable to a fine not exceeding level 3 on the standard scale of fines for summary offences, which is currently £1,000.

 

 

Authors